Windows Vista or XP?
http://live.pirillo.com/ – Ed in Detroit wants to know if his dad, who will be buying a new computer in the near future, should install Windows XP or Windows Vista.
Chris has dealt with this problem in the past (just check out his blog), and he isn’t entirely ready to tell people to go out and buy Vista. If it’s a new system, then they’ll probably have a better time with Vista, but Chris does encourage people to wait until; Service Pack 1 comes out.
If you want to install XP on the system you need to format the drive, and then install XP. If you install XP over Vista, it won’t work properly.
Do you have any recommendations?
Want to embed our Vista or XP? video in your blog? Use this code:
Formats available: MPEG4 Video (.mp4), MP3 Audio (.mp3), Microsoft Video (.avi), Flash Video (.flv)
What's your #1 source for Internet needs? GoDaddy has new domain names, transfers and renewals as low as $1.99. Plus, check out their hosting plans, Web site builders, secure certificates and much more. Plus, as a listener of The Chris Pirillo Show, enter code CHRIS1 when you check out, and save an additional 10% on any order. Get your piece of the internet at GoDaddy!






13 Comments
Jaxim
June 11th, 2007
at 3:50pm
If his dad is buying a NEW computer, then I would suggest that he buy one with Vista. Most likely than not, the new computers can handle Vista; and why make him wait to install it later which is a bit of a hassle.
LeSage
June 12th, 2007
at 4:32pm
An 82-year-old cousin has just bought a brand-new Lenovo (was IBM) laptop with Vista. It has only 512 MB of RAM, and is as slow as a wet week. Didn’t like to spoil her pleasure by telling her. Here in New Zealand several big appliance stores are advertising this configuration. Expect a lot of disapppointed people.
True Love
June 12th, 2007
at 4:53pm
I agree with Jaxim. I bought a new computer with Vista installed and it works just fine. Other than Vista being a memory hog, I don’t have any complaints. To upgrade to Vista from XP would definately be a headache, I’ve tried it, I wouldn’t advise it.
True Love
June 12th, 2007
at 4:53pm
I agree with Jaxim. I bought a new computer with Vista installed and it works just fine. Other than Vista being a memory hog, I don’t have any complaints. To upgrade to Vista from XP would definately be a headache, I’ve tried it, I wouldn’t advise it.
Dennis J. Betts
June 12th, 2007
at 7:22pm
Here’s my take on Vista,
I have had NO problems at all with my “virginal” installation of Vista Home Premium on a freshly re-formatted hard drive (done on March 10, 2007)and no problems with the “automatic” Vista updates. I run Rhinoceros 4, CS2 versions of PhotoShop and Illustrator, Office 2003 and the usual run of FPS games. Here’s my rig:
Mobo: ECS755-A2 (socket 754 board, AGP, SiS chipset) (retail)
CPU: Athlon 64 3000+ (Newcastle Family “F”, Model “C”) (retail)
RAM: two modules 512 Mb PC3200 DDR (”Extreme Performance” by Patriot)
Hard Drives: two WD Caviar WD1200JB
Video: XFX GeForce 7600GT (AGP bus) 560 Mhz, 256 Mb, DDR3 (retail)
Power Supply: Works Ultra Quiet 400 Watts (AMD approved)
Sound: SoundBlaster Audigy 2 “Value” Model SB0400 (retail)
Vista tells me that my bottleneck is the CPU giving me a score of 4.1 and that’s good enough for me until Direct X 10 is firmly entrenched and then I’ll upgrade. So far, no problems in games and no problems in 3D design creations.
I don’t know why all the fuss about Vista. I’ve been building PCs (ahem, assembling PCs) for over 20 years and I never run into the problems I read that other folks are having—call it luck, eh!
Cheers,
Dennis
leftystrat
June 12th, 2007
at 8:35pm
There are more than two operating systems, folks…
Ubuntu Feisty Fawn is getting ever closer to `Ready for Prime Time’.
Without more info about the gent using the computer, it’s hard to say.
As a rule, it’s best to avoid new MS software at least til the first service pack (or fifth). If it must be Windows, XP is certainly a proven quantity and won’t require hideous amounts of horsepower to simply boot up. This way the computer is faster out of the gate.
You can always try out other operating systems via live cd’s or virtual machines.
Best of luck!
leftystrat
June 12th, 2007
at 8:35pm
There are more than two operating systems, folks…
Ubuntu Feisty Fawn is getting ever closer to `Ready for Prime Time’.
Without more info about the gent using the computer, it’s hard to say.
As a rule, it’s best to avoid new MS software at least til the first service pack (or fifth). If it must be Windows, XP is certainly a proven quantity and won’t require hideous amounts of horsepower to simply boot up. This way the computer is faster out of the gate.
You can always try out other operating systems via live cd’s or virtual machines.
Best of luck!
john
June 13th, 2007
at 3:57am
if dad is buying a new computer suggest very seriouly that he looks into buying a MAC Here are several reasons: Ease of use Safari browser is what IE wants to be. Open office works just as well and is compatable with microsofr office and is a freebie. The biggest reason for me is that I am visually impaired and have to use on windows a 3rd party screen reader “Zoom Text” and a program that is every bit as good is built in to the Mac os. Take Dad to Mac store and have him check out the new Macs
john
June 13th, 2007
at 3:57am
if dad is buying a new computer suggest very seriouly that he looks into buying a MAC Here are several reasons: Ease of use Safari browser is what IE wants to be. Open office works just as well and is compatable with microsofr office and is a freebie. The biggest reason for me is that I am visually impaired and have to use on windows a 3rd party screen reader “Zoom Text” and a program that is every bit as good is built in to the Mac os. Take Dad to Mac store and have him check out the new Macs
jim combs
June 13th, 2007
at 7:22am
I WILL NOT EVEN THINK OF INSTALLING -VISTA OS- UNTILL THE BRIGHT
SO-CALLES GEEKS OF MICROSOFT GETS EVERYTHING RIGHT. I’M SO
SICK AND TIRED OF INSTALLING SO-CALLED UPGRADES AND FIXES T0
MY XP OS;S THAT I COULD JUST SCREAM///// WHAT IN THE HELL DOES
BILL GATES PAY THESE SO-CALLED GEEKS//// NOT $ 3.OO AN HOUR I BET. WHEN I WAS IN BUSSINESS IN FLORIDA ( SERVICE CENTER-AUTO}
IF I DID NOT GET IT RIGHT THE FIRST TIME THEN I WOULD FIRE THE ONE
WHO DID THE WORK AND RELEASED IT TO THE PUBLIC. AFTER A COUPLE
OF FIREING OF ENPLOYEE’S THE REST OF MY PEOPLE BEGAN TO GET IT RIGHTTHE THE FIRST TIME. AND THEN WE ALL MADE THE BOSS HAPPY{ ME}
EVEN BILL GATES WOULD AGREE WITH ME ON THAT ONE
GO BACK TO WINDOWS 98 OR 2000 AND REWORK THEM AND MAKE
EVERY COMPUTER QWNER HAPPY-/// ENOUGH FOR NOW
JIM
RENENBER~~~~~ RESTRUCTURING OF A BUSSINESS OFTEN PAYS OFF~~~
jim combs
June 13th, 2007
at 7:22am
I WILL NOT EVEN THINK OF INSTALLING -VISTA OS- UNTILL THE BRIGHT
SO-CALLES GEEKS OF MICROSOFT GETS EVERYTHING RIGHT. I’M SO
SICK AND TIRED OF INSTALLING SO-CALLED UPGRADES AND FIXES T0
MY XP OS;S THAT I COULD JUST SCREAM///// WHAT IN THE HELL DOES
BILL GATES PAY THESE SO-CALLED GEEKS//// NOT $ 3.OO AN HOUR I BET. WHEN I WAS IN BUSSINESS IN FLORIDA ( SERVICE CENTER-AUTO}
IF I DID NOT GET IT RIGHT THE FIRST TIME THEN I WOULD FIRE THE ONE
WHO DID THE WORK AND RELEASED IT TO THE PUBLIC. AFTER A COUPLE
OF FIREING OF ENPLOYEE’S THE REST OF MY PEOPLE BEGAN TO GET IT RIGHTTHE THE FIRST TIME. AND THEN WE ALL MADE THE BOSS HAPPY{ ME}
EVEN BILL GATES WOULD AGREE WITH ME ON THAT ONE
GO BACK TO WINDOWS 98 OR 2000 AND REWORK THEM AND MAKE
EVERY COMPUTER QWNER HAPPY-/// ENOUGH FOR NOW
JIM
RENENBER~~~~~ RESTRUCTURING OF A BUSSINESS OFTEN PAYS OFF~~~
keith
July 5th, 2007
at 10:53am
having 2 os on one puter i.e. vista & xp ..should this be partisioned on ??as two seprate os’s or like you said in the video “first xp ,then vista”??
promble is no audio when xp is in use..? audio with vista!
i know thatbtheb IS guy put vista first then xp..and they are partisioned.
ty,
k
Lance Gipson
December 20th, 2007
at 9:20am
Chris,
Have you seen issues with upgrading from Vista back to XP Pro??? I have a Gateway laptop here and its having issues with not seeing the “harddrive”. Do you know of any known issues about this. This could be just a true problem with the hard drive. Email me back for your input.
I cant stand VISTA. Im reloading so many pc’s and laptop back to XP, its unreal.
Lance G.