Set-Top Debate: Boxee vs Roku vs Apple TV

Streaming content in your home is quickly becoming much more than just a fad. People are cutting the cord in favor of set-top boxes such as Roku, Apple TV and Boxee. Using a device such as this gives the consumer more control over the content they can watch as well as being more cost-effective than traditional cable or satellite television connections. The question is, though, which box is right for your home? The three major players – Roku, Boxee and Apple TV – have many things in common. However, you’ll be surprised at how the differences between them can sway your purchasing decision.

Both the Roku and the Apple TV boxes can be purchased for under one hundred dollars, while the new Boxee model will set you back two hundred smackers. However, the Boxee alternative has quite a bit more to offer. At this point in time, Apple and Roku have some catching up to do in the content delivery department. Boxee now offers both Netflix and Vudu for your viewing pleasure. With Vudu, you can purchase movies on-demand – the same day they are released on DVD even – at a cost of $2.00 for two nights. Stream your favorite Internet content and connect with your Twitter and Facebook account in order to get suggestions from your friends. Additionally, personal recommendations will be sent straight to your television, based on your previous viewing choices. The unit is Flash 10.1 compatible, another feature the others don’t offer. There are more than 400 apps at this time, offering you third-party content distribution choices you haven’t even begun to think of. The remote control is double-sided, offering both a browsing experience and a full QWERTY keyboard. There’s an SD card slot and two USB ports built in.

The Roku box offers Netflix and Hulu, movie rental and purchases and even popular sports packages. There are more than fifty channels at this time – including Amazon video service. Stream your iTunes collection without a computer connection or tune in to your favorite online radio stations such as Pandora. The unit is capable of viewing YouTube and Flickr content, much as the others are. There is also a USB port which allows you to view media on your favorite USB stick.

Apple TV has a partnership with both FOX and ABC, allowing you to access your favorite shows for .99 per episode. If you want to watch an entire season, though, it could end up costing you quite a lot. This unit also offers Netflix, YouTube and Flickr access. Movies will cost you $2.99 or $3.00 for HD versions. There is one Micro USB slot and the cool remote allows you to access your iPod touch, iPad or iPhone with the press of a button. That in itself is seriously cool. Have you tried playing Angry Birds on the big screen yet?

Even though the Boxee set-top box has more to offer at this point in time, don’t count the Roku and Apple TV out just yet. I’m sure we will be seeing revisions to both machines sometime this year. Competition in this market is fierce, and I have a feeling that we’ll see even better features coming in the new versions.

Are you using a set-top box in your home? Which model do you own, and what do you prefer about it?

8 thoughts on “Set-Top Debate: Boxee vs Roku vs Apple TV”

  1. Boxee all the way, but i use it on old pcs that i have… throw a decent video card in it.. and im all set.. if the windows lic isnt available, use ubuntu.. the only drawback on using ubuntu is the lack of netflix…

  2. Living in Canada affects the choice of box as not all services are available up here in the ‘Great White North’.

    Personally I wasn’t looking for a box full of tricks (I previously had a Windows Media Centre Hooked up) – I realized that I don’t want to get my email on my TV, nor do I want to browse the web, tweet and facebook from it either. Believe it or not – but all I want to do is watch TV!

    And that’s where Apple shines! Sure their products cost more and have less features than the competition – but they do what they are designed to do and they do it well.

    If your a tech-head and you want the ability to multi-task your media device so you can run shell scripts while watching Battlestar Galactica and tweeting with your chums – then Apple TV is not for you!

    If you want a consumer device thats cheap, simple to use, integrates beautifully with your existing Apple investments (Air Play) and looks pretty with your Home Theatre equipment – then I vote for Apple TV!

  3. people arent cord cutting – they are cord shaving eg supplementing content not cutting back on.

    until nfl/mlb/cnn etc are available live on demand over the net then people wont cut entirely.

  4. Finally, you don’t have a bias of Apple Products. I APPLAUD YOU CHRIS! I AM GLAD YOU NOW SEE THE TRUE SCAM (MACS spelled backwards) THAT IS APPLE!

  5. I have the WD TV Live Plus. Right now it offers Blockbuster, YouTube, Netflix, MediaFly and etc…integration w. Facebook. You can upload pics or video to the site. Best feature is that it can play a huge number of formats, via the USB, streaming from the computer or NAS. This device can be bought for about $100 +/-.

  6. I’m still quite happy with my WDTV Live, though it isn’t a Plus version, but since Netflix isn’t available in Europe I don’t count that as the slightest advantage. Of course, I have installed the WDLXTV custom firmware to make it more insteresting to use 🙂

  7. I am not too impressed with an internet TV box that does not have a full web browser. This Roku would be useless for me. I am a DISH Network subscriber/employee, and I use the Logitech Revue with Google TV. With a well developed and friendly UI, I couldn’t be happier.

Comments are closed.