Microsoft’s Zune Competes with Microsoft
- 13
- Add a Comment
I don’t get it. Should I be using Napster, URGE, or Zune? Should I be using the Clix or the Zune? Should I be using Windows Media Player 11 or the Zune Marketplace software? There are too many choices, many of which are not interoperable, coming to me from the same company: Microsoft. Instead of simplifying the market, they’ve made it slightly more complicated with Zune (and likely pissed off countless partners in the process).
So, on one hand, I’m being told that URGE in combo with WMP is the way to go. On the other hand, I’m being told that Zune is the way to go (hardware, software, subscription) is the way to go. I certainly appreciate that there’s somewhat of a unified experience with Zune, but… now I have one more subscription to worry about… one more piece of software to worry about… and yet more choices that seem to completely nullify earlier efforts of Microsoft (itself) and its partners.
That I can see, there’s no clear cross-over between the Zune and Windows Media Center, for me to take my recorded shows on the go (since the Zune plays video). There’s no interaction with any other Microsoft product other than Windows. There’s no path to personalized media (podcasting, DVD ripping, etc.). In the interviews I’ve read, all of this is by design.
It’s almost like Microsoft is competing with itself - like it’s taking a mulligan on all earlier efforts in the digital media space.


13 Comments
Alijah Green
September 14th, 2006
at 2:25pm
Chris you want everything but nothing at all. Between the way you critique Microsoft and apple I am get confused. Your mad at apple for not opening up the iPod/iTunes, now your mad cause Microsoft opened a new store for everyone to consume from. I just don’t get. hey why don’t you make one those cute cartoons for me.
ellay
September 14th, 2006
at 7:47pm
Chris,
Thanks for your comments from a user’s point of view. It has gotten so confusing - anything having to do with MP3 -that I’ve decided to go back to enjoying my simple shelf top CD system.
I sure hope the next wave is about less innovation and more improvement on what’s already there and works okay but could be better. I think we could all get behind that (I don’t know if big corporate boards of directors and major shareholders could, though.)
Microsoft Zune and Podcasting - Will We Feel the Luv? | Zune Luv?
September 14th, 2006
at 8:27pm
Actually, the product sounds like something that is trying to be all things to all people and is simply turning out to be nothing to nobody. Chris Pirillo is right, the product not only doesn’t make sense for the average user, it doesn’t even make sense for Microsoft. There are those who will quote back to me my favorite phrase: to get to rev. 2, you have to have rev. 1. But, sometimes, rev. 1 reveals that there is no need or reason for a rev. 2. I’m not feeling the (Zune) luv right now.
Cale Bruckner
September 15th, 2006
at 9:10am
KISS. Keep it Simple Stupid. Apple has 75% of the MP3 player market because the IPOD (the whole product line) is SIMPLE. SIMPLE makes it easy to market. It’s easy to market because simplicity makes it easy for Apple and more importantly consumers to pitch it. I’m a PC guy but I’ve sold at least a dozen people on the IPOD because the benefits of using it to manage music are easy to pitch in simple conversations without sounding like a total geek and I can feel good about pitching it because it just work. SIMPLE makes it easy to use and keep using. SIMPLE makes it easy for partners to invest in. SIMPLE makes it easy to cross-sell users into add-ons and small, medium, and large sizes of the same thing. SIMPLE is why iTV might get Apple into the livingroom in a big way.
Matt
September 15th, 2006
at 10:01am
Chris -
You’re so right on the money. As a PC user, Microsoft couldn’t have dropped the ball on this any harder. They’ve never figured out how to do the one-box-solution to digital media, instead opting to license their wares to anyone who thought they might take a crack at it on their behalf.
bdo radio #057 at b•o | radio
September 17th, 2006
at 11:06pm
[...] [18:21] - Microsoft Zune Competes With Microsoft [...]
ClicZune
September 18th, 2006
at 8:23am
Zune seems to be the only device that can compete with the ipod. And apple needs a competitor right now because they are going to stop to innovate. At the end, consumers are going to win with better and better players.
sportsunit
September 21st, 2006
at 6:28pm
It does interact with other Microsoft products, namely the 360. You can connect it to the 360 and stream videos, music, and photos. I’m almost positive more integration is coming down the line, or I may have to sell the Zune that I’m going to end up buying.
Greg's Cool [Insert Clever Name] of the Day
September 26th, 2006
at 3:57pm
Chris Pirillo - Syncing Outlook, OS X, Google with Ease “Not sure how it happened, but I ran into The Holy Grail of Synchronization - how to synchronize Microsoft Outlook (multiple locations), Google Calendar, Gmail, iPod, and mobile phone with Funambol, ScheduleWorld…. … Standards to the rescue! Engtech, as described, pointed me to ScheduleWorld: “An experiment in a new kind of rich Internet
Gregarius » News
October 3rd, 2006
at 11:37am
easy-to-use spam filter that makes sure you get messages from people you know, while redirecting messages from people you don’t. There are no complicated rules or filters to create or manage: CA Anti-Spam does it for you. And it works seamlessly with Microsoft Outlook and Outlook Express. PC Magazine Editors’ Choice Award 3 years running! 20% off CA Personal Firewall (use code AFFFW20) - CA Personal Firewall provides complete, business-strength hacker and privacy protection. It stops hacker attacks,
Ryan Fenyves
October 23rd, 2006
at 6:13pm
I have to agree. Microsoft is making a complicated market. I’m an URGE subscriber (I don’t know for how long) so why should I think about purchasing a Zume. It seems to me that Zume is just another piece of proprietary **** like IPod. Why would you confuse the market when play for sure was just starting to roll? I also feel like going back to music pirating and cd burning. What a bunch of junk.
Patrick
November 19th, 2006
at 9:25pm
I agree with Chris. Some of us don’t want another store. I want to take my recorded TV with me. That is the #1 reason for buying the Zune. You can imagine how I felt when I went to hook it up and I couldn’t download my record TV. Of course, Microsoft doesn’t want to hear feedback and doesn’t provide an outlet. I guess they’ll have to wait for the disappointing sales to learn.
My Zune is going back to the store.
Dean
February 17th, 2007
at 11:52am
There are people who actually buy the Zune? I have yet to see one on the street. I thought we all knew better than to buy yet another one of Microsofts rip offs. I mean why buy the pretender? When you can buy the real thing! (iPod)
SocioBiblog
June 14th, 2007
at 12:50am
PC Magazine? Not!The Best and Worst Last Minute Christmas GiftsIt’s Time for Subscriptions!Gnomedex 7.0 DatesIM Getting Inc’edThe Best Podcasting Client for Windows?Work Work Work Work WorkAn HDTV ReminderMicrosoft’s Zune Competes with MicrosoftWant a Free 12-Month Xbox Live Gold Subscription?
Matthew Rutledge’s Blog Space
May 31st, 2008
at 6:41am
Battery Saving Tips for iPods and Zunes What Do You Want Your Media Player to Do? To Buy a Zune Podcasts Sound Better on the Zune Apple iPod vs Microsoft Zune I’m Not Buying a Zune!!! Zune: Good and BadMicrosoft’s Zune Competes with Microsoft